Compare Canara NSIGSE Savings Bank Deposit Account and Union Bank of India Savings Bank Account for Students (SBZER) using the controlling cost, balance, rate, tenure, liquidity, limits, eligibility and current first-party bank evidence for this product type.
Compare the two source-backed records without collapsing unlike conditions into a winner score.
Eligible SC/ST or Kasturba Gandhi Balika Vidyalaya girls entering qualifying Class IX schools under the NSIGSE implementation rules.
Students who want a public-sector zero-balance account with explicit age/course eligibility and a defined age-25 conversion point.
bankingreference.info · Comparison research sheet
Prepared 14 Sep 2026 · Source page: https://bankingreference.info/compare-banking/canara-nsigse-savings-bank-deposit-account-vs-union-bank-sbzer-student-savings-account/
General product research only. Recheck the listed first-party sources before acting because product terms can change after the recorded review dates.
Each checkpoint reproduces the recorded product fields instead of assigning a winner. Read the condition, scope and missing-data state before treating a difference as useful to you.
Source review: September 9, 2026
Maintenance: Within the scheduled review window
1 attached source. A review date is not a guarantee that terms have stayed unchanged.
Source review: September 9, 2026
Maintenance: Within the scheduled review window
2 attached sources. A review date is not a guarantee that terms have stayed unchanged.
The stored field wording is preserved. Product-type-specific evidence follows this generic comparison where deeper structured research exists.
On a small screen, scroll this table sideways. The factor column stays visible.
Table region. When the region itself has keyboard focus, use Left and Right arrows to scroll horizontally; Home and End move to the start or end.
| Decision factor | Canara NSIGSE Savings Bank Deposit Account | Union Bank of India Savings Bank Account for Students (SBZER) |
|---|---|---|
| Cost / charges | No stipulated minimum balance; the current Canara page also says no charge is levied for non-operation/activation of an inoperative NSIGSE account. | No minimum balance requirement under the current SBZER product page; nil NEFT charges are highlighted. Other service/card charges remain subject to the bank's current schedule. |
| Balance / relationship | No minimum balance requirement under the scheme-specific account terms. | No minimum balance requirement while the customer remains eligible for SBZER. |
| Core benefits | Digital banking services, debit-card availability, cash/electronic credits and scheme-specific handling intended to support continued secondary-school enrolment. | Debit-card access with ₹2 lakh personal accidental death cover under current terms, internet/mobile banking, cheque access and nil NEFT charges. |
| Limits / allowances | Withdrawals are mainly through withdrawal slips; no cheque book is issued until the student attains majority. Other minor-account procedures continue to apply. | Union Bank currently publishes ₹25,000 daily ATM cash-withdrawal limit and ₹50,000 daily POS limit for the student proposition. |
| Eligibility | Eligible SC/ST girls who pass Class VIII, plus eligible Kasturba Gandhi Balika Vidyalaya girls irrespective of SC/ST status who enroll in qualifying Class IX government/government-aided/local-body schools under the scheme. Other exclusions on the bank page apply. | Students above 10 and up to 25 years pursuing regular courses. Accounts of student minors below 10 are operated by parent/guardian under current product FAQs. |
| Ongoing relationship rule | Government-linked student account. Canara says debit cards are available but does not name a specific card variant, so no exact card edge is created. | Student-status relationship. Union Bank's published conversion notice states SBZER converts to normal savings after age 25, when ordinary savings-account terms apply. |
A useful comparison shows what can make either option unsuitable instead of averaging those conditions into a score.
These tools help narrow or inspect the records. They do not replace bank eligibility, live pricing or account-specific controls.
One side's source depth or freshness never fills a gap in the other record.
These are the exact source URLs already attached to the two research records. Re-open the controlling documents before relying on a fee, rate, limit, eligibility rule or benefit.
Reviewed September 9, 2026 · 1 attached first-party source
Reviewed September 9, 2026 · 2 attached first-party sources